In a dramatic exchange that has reignited the debate over football’s most coveted individual accolade, Manchester City midfielder Rodri has fired back at Cristiano Ronaldo, insisting that his 2024 Ballon d’Or award is beyond question. The Spanish international’s triumph in the prestigious award has drawn attention and controversy, with Ronaldo himself questioning the decision, arguing that Brazilian winger Vinícius Júnior deserved the prize over Rodri.
Rodri, who played a pivotal role in Manchester City’s historic treble-winning season and Spain’s victory at the European Championship, was named the 2024 Ballon d’Or winner in a ceremony held in Paris last October. However, his victory over Vinícius, a key figure in Real Madrid’s Champions League and La Liga double, has sparked fierce debate, especially among some of the game’s legends.
Ronaldo, a five-time Ballon d’Or winner himself, publicly expressed his surprise and disapproval over the choice. “Vinícius should have won it,” Ronaldo stated, referring to the Brazilian’s dazzling performances during Madrid’s triumphant season. “He won the Champions League and scored in the final. It’s a shame that the award didn’t go to him.”
However, in an exclusive interview with Diario AS, Rodri took a firm stand, making it clear that he would not let the criticism slide.
“It was a surprise to me, really,” Rodri began, addressing the controversy. “Cristiano knows better than anyone how the Ballon d’Or works. He’s won it five times, so he’s no stranger to the process. The truth is, the journalists who voted for me have made their decision. This year, they considered that I should win it. These are the same journalists who voted for him in the past, and I imagine he was happy with their choices back then.”
Rodri’s words underscore the importance of the voting process, which is carried out by a panel of international sports journalists who evaluate players based on their performances over the past calendar year. While Ronaldo’s comments suggest a preference for Vinícius Júnior’s achievements, Rodri’s accomplishments cannot be dismissed lightly.
Rodri, 28, was instrumental in both his club’s domestic and international success. At Manchester City, he helped guide the team to a historic treble, clinching the Premier League, FA Cup, and the UEFA Champions League title under Pep Guardiola. On the international stage, Rodri’s defensive solidity and leadership were key to Spain’s victory in the 2024 UEFA European Championship, cementing his reputation as one of the best midfielders in the world.
While Vinícius Júnior’s contributions to Real Madrid’s Champions League success were undeniably impressive, it is clear that Rodri’s performances across both club and country in 2024 placed him at the forefront of the Ballon d’Or race. In the eyes of many, his all-around excellence throughout the season made him a worthy winner.
Yet, despite this, the controversy around his victory has only deepened since the ceremony. In an unprecedented move, Real Madrid decided to boycott the 2024 Ballon d’Or gala, reportedly in protest of Rodri’s win over their star player. Sources close to the club revealed that top officials within the Madrid hierarchy felt the award was undeserved, given the “historical importance” of Vinícius’s performances.
The rift between the two clubs – Manchester City and Real Madrid – is no stranger to the football world. With the intense rivalry between the two European giants reaching new heights in recent seasons, the Ballon d’Or controversy has only added fuel to the fire. This clash is not just a sporting issue, but also a matter of pride and prestige for the two clubs, each of which claims to be at the peak of European football.
Rodri, however, remains unshaken by the criticism, and his calm yet firm response speaks volumes about his confidence. “I respect everyone’s opinion, but the journalists have spoken,” he said, pointing to the 2024 voting panel. “It’s not up to any individual player to dictate the outcome. The award is not about one opinion; it’s about the collective judgment of experts.”
The debate over the 2024 Ballon d’Or extends beyond Ronaldo and Vinícius. For many fans and pundits, the fact that Rodri was chosen highlights the evolving nature of the award itself. While attackers like Ronaldo and Vinícius have often dominated the spotlight, Rodri’s win signals the growing appreciation for midfielders and defensive players who contribute to their teams’ success in less flashy but equally important ways.
Rodri’s victory also raises questions about the future of the Ballon d’Or and the criteria for selecting winners. Traditionally, the award has been centered around goals and assists, with forwards often taking the spotlight. However, in recent years, players like Luka Modrić (2018) and now Rodri are showing that a well-rounded, influential presence in the midfield or defensive roles can be just as impactful as scoring goals.
“I think this year’s award is a sign of change,” Rodri continued. “Football is evolving, and so should the way we view and reward performances. You don’t have to be a forward to make a difference. Football is about the whole team, and my role in both City and Spain this year was crucial.”
Indeed, Rodri’s stellar season was not limited to his work on the ball. His tireless defensive contributions, leadership, and ability to dictate play from midfield made him an essential cog in both of his team’s triumphs. For City, his ability to break up opposition attacks and transition the ball smoothly from defense to attack was instrumental in their successful campaign. For Spain, his performances in the heart of midfield helped steer his country to continental glory.
As for Ronaldo, while his criticism has sparked debate, it has also highlighted the relentless pursuit of perfection that has defined his career. The Portuguese icon, now in the twilight of his career, remains one of the most influential figures in world football. But even as his legendary status is secure, his public comments about Rodri’s Ballon d’Or victory reflect the competitive fire that still burns within him.
